Monday, 8 December 2008

Gay Marriage

Today I attempt to discuss the controversial issue of gay marriage. This is actually half Boote's fault for joining the facebook causes 'support gay marriage' and half facebook's fault for alerting me to this fact. It is an issue I haven't really thought much about before, and I'm still not totally sure where I stand upon the issue, so I encourage others to add their own viewpoints to see what other people think about the issue, because my mind is still very much undecided.

Firstly, and I'll get this out of the way early on, under the title of this cause on facebook is the line:

don't allow people to vote against gay marrage ! they're people too !!

And I actually don't like this sentiment on the grounds of basic human rights, and on the basis of democracy, which is currently the least bad form of government we have. It is a human right to be able to make a choice. To be able to cast your vote on issues. If you agree with this sentence then unfortunately you might as well destroy democracy and live in a dictatorship. You cannot, and never should be able to, disallow someone the right to vote a certain way on issues. However, I suspect this sentiment is directed towards simply not standing by and allowing this to happen. that is the continual denial on gay marriage, as opposed to actually imposing restriction on votes that are able to be cast, and that it is just poorly worded.

Moving on, my initial reaction was that gay marriage should be allowed. However, it isn't actually gay marriage as an ideal which is banned. It is simply gay marriage by name. In the UK and most of the US gay couples are allowed to enter into civil partnerships which award these couples the same rights as married heterosexual couples. The only difference being that in name they are not 'married'. However they are married in all but name.

The main problem is that these two countries are based upon so called Christian beliefs. And marriage is, ultimately, a religious joining of two people. A religion which does at least hint towards homosexuality being a sin. And therefore, on the very grounds of those religions gay people cannot get married. And I'm sorry if I'm going all Richard Dawkins a moment, but if it's a choice between insulting religious people, and a different group of people then religion always gets its way. You simply cannot insult religious people. It is a social faux pas beyond all others. And so the law continues to stand.

And so this leaves me with the slightly bewildering notion that gay people are going about this all wrong. Don't push for equal rights on the name of marriage. Because who wants to be joined religiously in a religion that tells you you are sinning for simply being who you are. Instead I would push for further segregation. Encourage non-Christian heterosexuals to abandon marriage, and to instead enter into civil partnerships. This is, however unlikely to occur, but just imagine a moment, a world where few people are actually married because that marriage is based upon an outdated notion that is no longer applicable in today's society. A world where sensible, free-thinking individuals are joined by law in ceremonies to their own choosing that are marriages in all but name. I would hope even a large proportion of Christians (and those of other religions) would stand up on this issue and abandon marriage by name preferring to follow their own morals, and their own interpretation of their holy books, and then we could all stand together and shun the narrow minded people left behind who believe acting upon gay impulses is a sin.

This is, of course, a pipe dream. But the fact remains that this country needs to redefine it's official religion rapidly. We need a New Church of England. One that not only allows divorce, but allows gay marriage. Ultimately the only one who can enforce such a change is, and please excuse the terrible pun, ironically, the most famous Queen of all.

9 comments:

Boote said...

lmao @ your pun.

You pointed me in the direction of this blog for my opinion so here it is: I agree. I agree in a civil union that grants couples (not just gay couples but couples who are athiest or agnostic) the same rights as marriage. Now I'm nto all clued up about civil union and marriage but from what I've gotten from gay people is that there's levels of civil unions and not all civil unions grant all the same rights as marriage. However as I said I'm nto clued up on this and only going on the wave of disappointment following the passing of prop 8.

Quick correction: Only about 7 states actually have civil unions, with 3 other states having a decision on marriage/civil unions being debated.

To be honest the main reason why I say "I'm not getting married" is due to the fact it is a religious cerimony of a religion I don't agree with so marriage would be very hypicritical of me. Not that I'm calling gay people hypicrits for getting married I mean this is the way for them to have the same rights as every other couple and don't blame them. I like to think given the choice between religious marriage and state marriage they'll take the state marriage.

Now just for fun a jointy tune about prop 8 featuring Jack Black: http://www.funnyordie.com/videos/c0cf508ff8/prop-8-the-musical-starring-jack-black-john-c-reilly-and-many-more-from-fod-team-jack-black-craig-robinson-john-c-reilly-and-rashida-jones

just_a_guy said...

Oh thanks for the correction, I'd forgotten how bible heavy central America was.

In fact, I find this map shows how irritating those bible states are due to its pink line down the centre of the US

http://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Image:Samesex_marriage_in_USA.svg

Boote said...

How'd your attempt at discussing gay amrriage go anyways? Did you get anywhere?

Anonymous said...

Just because Steve loves picking holes in other people's writing, i thought i'd add my own comments.

A: The 40 million inhabitants of Belize, Guatemala, El Salvador, Honduras, Nicaragua, Costa Rica, and Panama called, they'd like to have the term "Central America" back. Mexico was indifferent.

B: I was under the impression that the Church of England DID allow divorce already, in fact wasn't that precisely the reason that Henry the VIII founded it?

C: I agree with you're arguement pretty much.

I'm not really clued up on the legalities of it, but in my opinion, if Civil Partnerships give the same rights as marriage in all but name, then problem solved. Anyone that campaigns to be allowed to be married, is being awkard. As long as people are afforded the same rights, regardless of their sexual orientation, then i don't think it's really worth arguing over whether they can or can't use the term "married".

And that's a valid point, when you said that it's a religious term, from a religion that has persecuted and looked down upon gay people for, well a few hundred years.

As long as we get it right in this country, then we can get back to mocking the huge bible bashing contingent in America, who would prefer it if we all still lived in the dark ages.

In summary, i have too much time on my hands now that i am home.

And feel that we should all meet soon so that we can discuss other such random things. And possibly play some mario kart. Rob

Anonymous said...

P.S I'm an idiot that still uses the wrong form of you're/your.

just_a_guy said...

Thanks for your comment Rob, I did feel the need to reply due to your annoying preciseness. So I figured I'd be annoyingly precise in response.

A: Good point, but everyone uses the words America and USA interchangeably and you know it! Also even if all 40 million inhabitants had access to the internet and telephones, I doubt they all called you.

B: You misread my post

C: Yeah, lets all go out Saturday

sneg said...
This comment has been removed by the author.
sneg said...
This comment has been removed by the author.
sneg said...

Regarding differences between civil unions etc. Have a look at:
http://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Civil_union#United_Kingdom

UK is actually very lax with this sort of thing. :)