Monday, 20 April 2009

Freshly Cleaved HOPG

So some lecturers can't lecture. And some can't make handouts. Today's award for poor lecturing goes to Dr Charl Faul.


Here is Dr Faul:


Anyway, the reason I don't like Dr Faul can be summarised with this slide entitled HBC.

HBC

  • organisation in LC phases
  • organisation on freshly cleaved HOPG
  • crystallisation in monolayers at liquid-graphite interface
  • direct imaging by STM

I have several issues with this slide. The first is that he didn't mention what HBC stood for. I assumed it stood for hexabenzocoronene, as this was mentioned somewhere else in the handout.

Next HOPG isn't explained at all. Nowhere in the hand out is this explained. Wikipedia told me it stood for 'highly ordered pyrolytic graphite'. That wasn't very useful.

But I could forgive all this if it wasn't for the more pressing matter that the slide didn;t seem to tell me anything useful. As far as I can tell you can make crystals of HBC on HOPG and look at them using STM. There's nothing there that I can be examined on surely. I mean, what would an exam question be?

And ok, so I could just ignore this slide and learn the rest, yeah? Well, the main problem with Dr Faul is that EVERY SINGLE SLIDE is like this too. No real information. Bullet points that make no sense. My annotations amount to "a thing --->". And sometimes its even worse- instead of telling you non-statements he tells us non-questions with bullet points consisting of things like 'synthesis and yields problematic?'

I'm so glad he put THAT in his handout.

Stupid Dr man. Can't even smile right.

2 comments:

The ex said...

i have lecturers who do very similar things, tho on less complex matters... more on 14th century france and then suddenly move onto the expansion of the byzantine empire!!
so yeh, lots of sympathy, and he definately has a weird half-grimace!

just_a_guy said...

Just for the record his exam question was the stupidest exam question I have ever had. I have no idea if I got it right and I hate the man.